Buffalo Bills Career Kicking Leaders

Team Names: Buffalo Bills

Seasons: 67 (1960 to 2026)

Record (W-L-T): 498-510-8

Playoff Record: 22-23

Super Bowls Won: 0 (4 Appearances)

Championships Won*: 2

All-time Passing Leader: Jim Kelly 2,874/4,779, 35,467 yds, 237 TD

All-time Rushing Leader: Thurman Thomas 2,849 att, 11,938 yds, 65 TD

All-time Receiving Leader: Andre Reed 941 rec, 13,095 yds, 86 TD

All-time Scoring Leader: Steve Christie 1,011 points

All-time AV Leader: Bruce Smith 201 AV

Winningest Coach (including playoffs): Marv Levy 123-78-0

Become a Stathead & surf this site ad-free.

Buffalo Bills Menu

Kicking

Kicking Table
							0-19		20-29		30-39		40-49		50+		Scoring						Kickoffs
Rk	Player	From	To	G	Pos	AV	FGA	FGM	FGA	FGM	FGA	FGM	FGA	FGM	FGA	FGM	FGA	FGM	FG%	XPA	XPM	XP%	KO	KOYds	TB	TB%	KOAvg
1	Tyler Bass	2020	2024	83	K	14	1	1	39	38	50	43	42	33	23	16	155	131	84.5%	274	264	96.4%	490	30907	298	60.8%	63.1
2	Booth Lusteg	1966	1966	14	K	2	10	8	5	3	8	4	11	4	4		38	19	50.0%	42	41	97.6%
3	Pete Gogolak	1964	1965	28	K	9	19	19	15	11	23	14	11	3	7		75	47	62.7%	77	76	98.7%
4	Steve Christie	1992	2000	144	K	28	7	7	87	79	96	78	81	57	28	13	299	234	78.3%	313	309	98.7%	689	41756	93	13.5%	60.6
5	Mike Hollis	2002	2002	16	K	3			8	7	10	8	10	7	5	3	33	25	75.8%	40	40	100.0%	84	4845	2	2.4%	57.7
6	Matt Prater	2025	2025	15	K	3			4	4	8	7	6	6	2	1	20	18	90.0%	49	46	93.9%	84	5093	11	13.1%	60.6
7	Dan Carpenter	2013	2016	64	K	12	1	1	36	36	32	30	36	28	21	14	126	109	86.5%	149	137	91.9%	156	9653	62	39.7%	61.9
8	Stephen Hauschka	2017	2019	48	K	11			14	14	25	24	29	23	21	12	89	73	82.0%	87	84	96.6%	213	12848	109	51.2%	60.3
9	Joe Danelo	1983	1984	23	K	1			9	7	10	7	10	3	7	1	36	18	50.0%	52	50	96.2%
10	Mike Mercer	1967	1968	17	K	4	3	3	6	3	7	4	14	5	1	1	31	16	51.6%	29	29	100.0%
11	Tom Dempsey	1978	1979	19	K	3	1	1	5	5	7	4	4	1			17	11	64.7%	49	44	89.8%
12	Rian Lindell	2003	2012	152	K	31	3	3	89	85	79	73	75	51	24	13	270	225	83.3%	306	305	99.7%	648	39468	62	9.6%	60.9
13	Nick Mike-Mayer	1979	1982	47	K	7			20	17	26	17	32	14	2		80	48	60.0%	99	95	96.0%
14	Billy Atkins	1960	1963	29	DB	26	3	3	3	1	11	3	2	1			19	8	42.1%	64	56	87.5%
15	Grant Guthrie	1970	1971	20	K	3	3	3	5	3	5	3	9	2	7	2	29	13	44.8%	34	32	94.1%
16	George Jakowenko	1976	1976	11	K	3			4	4	6	4	7	4			17	12	70.6%	24	21	87.5%
17	Scott Norwood	1985	1991	108	K	19	3	3	53	47	57	44	61	37	10	2	184	133	72.3%	278	271	97.5%	16	892	2	12.5%	55.8
18	Bruce Alford	1968	1969	25	K	6	10	9	15	12	10	7	13	2	2	1	50	31	62.0%	39	38	97.4%
19	Jake Arians	2001	2001	10	K	0			6	6	4	2	11	4			21	12	57.1%	17	16	94.1%	2	26			13.0
20	Cookie Gilchrist	1962	1964	42	FB	34	4	2	5	2	3	2	6	2	2		20	8	40.0%	17	14	82.4%
21	Dave Rayner	2011	2011	7	K	0			6	5	4	3	1		4	2	15	10	66.7%	13	13	100.0%	30	1740	7	23.3%	58.0
22	John Leypoldt	1971	1976	65	K	15	13	12	25	17	30	22	42	21	11	2	121	74	61.2%	158	147	93.0%
23	Efren Herrera	1982	1982	7	K	0	1	1	2	1	4	2	7	4			14	8	57.1%	12	11	91.7%
24	Carson Long	1977	1977	9	K	3			2	2	3	2	6	3			11	7	63.6%	14	13	92.9%
25	Chuck Nelson	1984	1984	7	K	1					2	1	3	2			5	3	60.0%	14	14	100.0%
26	Shayne Graham	2001	2001	6	K	1			4	4			4	2			8	6	75.0%	7	7	100.0%	21	1165			55.5
27	Neil O'Donoghue	1977	1977	5	K	0			2	1	2	1	1		1		6	2	33.3%	5	4	80.0%
28	Todd Schlopy	1987	1987	3	K	-1			1	1	3	1	1				5	2	40.0%	2	1	50.0%
29	Fred Steinfort	1983	1983	2	K	-1			1	1	2		3				6	1	16.7%	1	1	100.0%
Rk	Player	From	To	G	Pos	AV	FGA	FGM	FGA	FGM	FGA	FGM	FGA	FGM	FGA	FGM	FGA	FGM	FG%	XPA	XPM	XP%	KO	KOYds	TB	TB%	KOAvg
30	Benny Ricardo	1976	1976	2	K	-1			3	1					1		4	1	25.0%	2	2	100.0%
31	Michael Badgley	2025	2025	2	K	0							1	1			1	1	100.0%	4	2	50.0%	8	391			48.9
32	Darrell Harper	1960	1960	4	HB	1					3	2					3	2	66.7%	2	1	50.0%
33	Mack Yoho	1960	1963	56	LDE	34	4	4	5	3	12	3	14	3	1		36	13	36.1%	57	52	91.2%
34	Brandon Coutu	2011	2011	1	K	0							1				1		0.0%	3	3	100.0%	4	246			61.5
35	Joe Hergert	1960	1961	19	LB	8	2	2	5	2	7	3	4	1			18	8	44.4%
36	Bill Shockley	1961	1961	2	HB	0			1	1			1				2	1	50.0%
37	Tommy O'Connell	1960	1961	15	QB	3			1								1		0.0%
38	Bob Chandler	1971	1979	116	WR	47														1	1	100.0%
39	Ralph Felton	1961	1962	18	LLB	10														1		0.0%

More Buffalo Bills Pages

Bills History

Career Leaders

Season Leaders

History

People

Other

Buffalo Bills Career Kicking Leaders

Kicking

More Buffalo Bills Pages

Full Site Menu

FAQs, Tip & Tricks